The “Wrong Shoe Theory” is the easiest styling trick to spice up your outfit
If you’ve been on the Internet recently, you might’ve heard something about the so-called “Wrong Shoe Theory”. But what is it? And how can it help you improve your style?
Coined by stylist and wardrobe consultant Allison Bornstein, the “wrong shoe theory” is actually quite straightforward: the styling hack consists in finishing off an outfit that feels boring or monotonous with the “wrong” shoe, aka the one that seems to go “against” the rest of the look. The result? A perfectly imperfect look full of personality.
In regards to her groundbreaking discovery, Bornstein told Vogue: “In working with clients and breaking down the style of our favourite celebrities, I realised what makes a look feel interesting and personal is the addition of accessories that feel slightly ‘off’ or mismatched with the vibe of the rest of the look.” And she couldn’t be more right.
Tibi’s Creative Director Amy Smilovich champions a similar idea in the intro to her column The Good Ick: “All things good, stylistically speaking, have that push/pull.” Both Smilovic and Bornstein are talking about the same thing: how to achieve that good friction between the elements of your day-to-day looks.
But, as we all know, an image is worth a thousand words, and learning how to implement the wrong shoe theory in your wardrobe is much easier when you have a visual reference. So, without further ado, here are ten wrong shoe outfits done right, and all the tips you need to recreate them.
1. A feminine dress with dad sneakers
Getty Images
Amy Smilovich talks about achieving a push/pull effect in terms of style, and that’s exactly what supermodel Vittoria Ceretti (right) is doing here. She paired a pleated mini dress with an oversized bomber, a leather handbag, scrunched up white socks, and black Adidas Samba sneakers. In this look, the push/pull effect created by the dress vs. the shoes (and the bomber vs. the handbag) is actually double: masculine/feminine and high/low fashion.
-50%
Ganni
Multicolour Pleated Georgette V-neck Flounce Mini Dress - Size 42 Mixed
£82.50
£165.00
GANNI
-50%
Ganni
Navy Denim Strap Mini Dress - Size 34 Organic Cotton Blue
£142.50
£285.00
GANNI
-50%
Staud
Pleated ponte and grosgrain maxi dress Red
£237.00
£475.00
Mytheresa
-50%
Ganni
Blue Pleated Georgette Flounce Smock Mini Dress - Size 32
£122.50
£245.00
GANNI
-43%
Fat Face
FatFace Jess Claret Velvet Skirt
£28.00
£49.50
FatFace
-50%
Ganni
Green Seersucker Check V-Neck Mini Dress
£97.50
£195.00
GANNI
If you’re looking for a way to how to style your cowboy boots, wrong shoe theory is the answer! Cowboy boots with baggy, ripped bermuda shorts is definitely so-bad-it’s-good territory, and we suggest you embrace it. If you’re feeling especially bold, try pairing your calf boots with sweat or biker shorts instead of denim shorts. I promise, in this case two wrongs do make a right!
A Gold E
Ramona denim Bermuda shorts Blue
£210.00
Mytheresa
-16%
Roy Rogers
Denim Shorts, female, Blue, W28, Bermuda in denim
£100.05
£119.63
Miinto
-30%
AG - Adriano Goldschmied
Ex-Boyfriend denim Bermuda shorts Blue
£157.00
£225.00
Mytheresa
-15%
Haikure
Denim Shorts, female, Black, W26, Belle Mid Bermuda Shorts
£176.73
£207.93
Miinto
-20%
Róhe
Denim Bermuda shorts Beige
£208.00
£260.00
Mytheresa
-25%
Mother
Cropped Jeans, female, Beige, W27, The Weekender Cropped Flared Jeans
£235.77
£314.94
Miinto
Citizens Of Humanity
Court denim Bermuda shorts Beige
£250.00
Mytheresa
-51%
Mother
The Trickster Bermuda denim shorts - Blue
£145.00
£295.00
FARFETCH
Ballet flats are back and more popular than ever—but that doesn’t mean we have to style them like we did in 2008. Try playing with proportions, and pair your ballet flats with the baggiest, most boy-ish trousers you own (jeans, cargos, slacks, even sweats!): you’ll have a look that’s both edgy and chic.
Serena Bute
Slouchy Jogger - Navy Blue
£245.00
Serena Bute
-35%
Department Five
Straight Fit Jeans, female, Blue, M, High Waist Straight Leg Jeans
£137.82
£210.55
Miinto
Serena Bute
Slouchy Jogger - Ecru White
£245.00
Serena Bute
Max Mara
Wide Trousers, female, Green, XS, Wide Trousers
£216.64
Miinto
Serena Bute
Slouchy Jogger - Grey
£245.00
Serena Bute
-14%
Levi's
Wide Jeans, female, Blue, W27, A8701-0008 Cropped Jeans
£108.53
£126.15
Miinto
Wrong shoe theory is all about the good tension, and good tension can be created by pairing “high” and “low” elements to create a striking outfit. Here, we’re paying the most casual item of all—the tracksuit—with shoes that are generally considered dressy and elegant, like heeled ballet pumps or kitten heels. Add a pair of rhinestoned sunglasses and a stretchy headband and you’ve got yourself the perfect Y2K look.
Diesel
side-stripe track pants - Black
£175.00
FARFETCH
The Upside
Monte side-stripe track pants - Blue
£140.00
FARFETCH
New Balance
Tapered Logo-Print Shell Track Pants Blue
£180.00
Mr Porter
Maison Margiela
elasticated-waist wide-leg track pants - Grey
£350.00
FARFETCH
AZ FACTORY
Sneaky kitten heel pumps - Gold
£413.00
FARFETCH
Senso
Teyana kitten heel sandals - White
£144.00
FARFETCH
Michael Michael Kors
Jess 60mm leather kitten-heel pumps - Pink
£190.00
FARFETCH
Versace Jeans Couture
bow-detail kitten heel sandals - Green
£309.00
FARFETCH
5. A skirt and platform Crocs
Getty Images
Is it just me, or are platform Crocs kind of cool? In recent years, the plastic clog brand has come out with a number of new platform models, from the iconic mule to sandals. If you value comfort above all, jump on the platform Crocs train and style them with a sleek maxi skirt and a blazer. Instantly cool!
Crocs
Wedges, female, Beige, 6 UK, Mega Crush Sandal
£82.65
Miinto
-23%
Crocs
Classic Mega Crush Womens Bone Sandals - Beige - Size UK 6
£53.63
£69.99
Secret Sales
-16%
Crocs
Mega Crush rubber sandals - Black
£83.00
£99.00
FARFETCH
-30%
Crocs
Black Triple Strap Sandals
£59.38
£84.83
Miinto
-17%
Crocs
Womens Classic Crush - Black - Size UK 8
£66.68
£79.99
Secret Sales
-30%
Crocs
Clogs, female, Beige, 7 UK, Mega Crush Classic Shoe
£67.29
£96.14
Miinto
-14%
Crocs
Womens Classic Crush Womens Sandals - Pink - Size: 8
£42.99
£49.99
lovethesales
6. Flip-flop sandals and tailored trousers
Getty Images
Flip-flops and tailored trousers are shaping up to be a big trend this year, with celebrities like Elle Fanning and Zoë Kravitz sporting the look. The juxtaposition of the quintessential chill shoe and the slouchy tailored trousers makes for an effortless yet sophisticated look.
Ilse Jacobsen
Tulip 1076N Textile Womens Comfort Sandals - Black - Size:UK 6
£14.27
Legend Footwear
Fat Face
FatFace Denim Vintage Double Strap Flip Flop
£25.00
FatFace
Mephisto
Mephisto Helen Nubuck Womens Hook and Loop Sandals - Red - Size:UK 10.5
£34.57
Legend Footwear
Fat Face
FatFace Portloe White Print Flip Flop
£15.00
FatFace
-40%
Tory Burch
Flip Flops, female, Beige, 3 UK, Ciabatta
£134.85
£226.20
Miinto
Tommy Hilfiger
Braided Padded Strap Serrated Flip-Flops
£45.00
Tommy Hilfiger
7. Denim shorts and heeled mules
Getty Images
Styling shorts in a way that makes you feel both grown-up and put-together is not an easy feat. The best trick to make denim shorts work is to elevate them with the right choice of shoes and tops. Berlin-based content creator Tina Haase turned her shorts from summer camp vibes to city chic by styling them with a romantic tube top, an oversized blazer, a flower choker, and heeled mules.
Tommy Hilfiger
Essential Small Reporter Bag Black
£70.00
Tommy Hilfiger
Antler
Large Cabin Suitcase In Antler Green - Icon Stripe
£200.00
Antler
On
Cloudpulse Next Black
£120.00
On
-30%
Tommy Hilfiger
Logo Lace-Up Trainers With Leather Blue
£63.00
£90.00
Tommy Hilfiger
Antler
Essential Tote Bag In Navy
£65.00
Antler
Clarks
Saltway Cove Leather Mens Slingbacks Sandals - Black - Size:UK 9
£14.27
Legend Footwear
Antler
Luggage Strap In Cobalt Blue
£22.00
Antler
Tommy Hilfiger
Logo Court Trainers With Leather White
£90.00
Tommy Hilfiger
8. A suit and a pair of clogs
Getty Images
On the other hand, a tailored suit often feels too grown-up, and a little stuffy. To make your suit less business and more casual, try pairing it with a pair of clogs for that good high/low tension that makes an outfit immediately unique.
Alegria
Seville Leather Womens Clogs Shoes - Oiled Brown - Size:UK 6.5
£24.42
Legend Footwear
Kurt Geiger
Clogs, female, Brown, 6 UK, Mansion Clog
£147.03
Miinto
Birkenstock
buckle suede mules - Neutrals Beige
£133.00
FARFETCH
A.Emery
The Louis Clogs - Womens - Suede
£180.00
Browns
-18%
UGG
Goldenstar clogs - Brown
£119.00
£145.00
FARFETCH
-6%
Crocs
Clogs, female, Beige, 8 UK, Stomp Lined Stucco Clog
£73.05
£77.43
Miinto
Is your social media feed full of influencers wearing Salomon and ASICS shoes? For that you have to blame gorpcore, one of the biggest trends of the year. Gorpcore embraces utilitarian and sportswear pieces—from trekking shoes, to running sunglasses, to Goretex windbreakers—and turns them into fashionable and trendy items.
But if camping-chic isn’t for you, here’s another, more romantic way to style your gorpcore shoes: pair them with a tulle skirt, colour-block stockings, and an oversized graphic top.
Tommy Hilfiger
Essential Small Reporter Bag Black
£70.00
Tommy Hilfiger
Antler
Large Cabin Suitcase In Antler Green - Icon Stripe
£200.00
Antler
On
Cloudpulse Next Black
£120.00
On
-30%
Tommy Hilfiger
Logo Lace-Up Trainers With Leather Blue
£63.00
£90.00
Tommy Hilfiger
Antler
Essential Tote Bag In Navy
£65.00
Antler
Clarks
Saltway Cove Leather Mens Slingbacks Sandals - Black - Size:UK 9
£14.27
Legend Footwear
Antler
Luggage Strap In Cobalt Blue
£22.00
Antler
Tommy Hilfiger
Logo Court Trainers With Leather White
£90.00
Tommy Hilfiger
When Solange does something, we can’t do anything but take notes! For her LA loft feature in Apartamento Magazine, the star wore a rugby shirt, sweat shorts, and the ubiquitous Miu Miu ballet flats.
Sports jerseys and ballet flats are two of the biggest trends right now, and when styled together they lead to super cool combinations: style them with a pair of mini shorts and you’ve got yourself an it-girl-worthy daytime look.
-31%
Yohji Yamamoto
Elite 5 Zidane Ls Football Jersey Black
£125.00
£180.00
Labels
-30%
New Balance
Atalanta BC Mens New Balance Football Match Jersey in Blue/Black Polyester, size Medium
£38.50
£55.00
New Balance
Tommy Hilfiger
Crest Relaxed Oversized T-Shirt Red
£75.00
Tommy Hilfiger
-40%
Tommy Hilfiger
Intarsia Logo V-Neck Mini Jumper Dress Black
£60.00
£100.00
Tommy Hilfiger
-40%
Tommy Hilfiger
Intarsia Logo V-Neck Mini Jumper Dress Pink
£60.00
£100.00
Tommy Hilfiger
-20%
adidas
adidas Performance Womens Germany 24 Away Jersey - Pink - Size X-Small
£63.90
£79.90
Secret Sales
